Is Grief Narcissistic?

Estimated reading time: 8 minutes, 52 seconds

Discovering Altruism as the Antidote to Love and Grief

“Can you please hold on for a moment? I need to make a quick phone call,” she asked. With my hand over the mouthpiece, I asked for a minute to handle the call. Since moving into Clara Martini’s Mansion, a one-bedroom place without heat or hot water, I had encouraged my colleagues to rent the larger apartment next door. Allowing their apartment to use the same phone number as mine was how I treated others as cousins. Until late November, I had not felt the need to make any calls, and the number of times people called for me could be counted on one hand. However, after meeting Jan, I constantly wanted to talk to her. What was supposed to be a minute-long interruption turned into over an hour. I realized that instead of being a considerate neighbor, I had selfishly focused only on my needs.

Kala: A Novel

I remember the evening when I stopped being altruistic and became a borderline narcissist after reading “Kala: A Novel” by Colin Walsh. Former friends, estranged for twenty years, reckon with the terrifying events of the summer that changed their lives. Three old friends are reunited in the seaside town of Kinlough, on Ireland’s west coast, for the first time in years. In the book, one of the protagonists, Helen, reflects on her grief about losing Kala, her best friend and falling in love. Helen says,

“Grief is like falling in love; it is always narcissistic. Some catastrophe cuts through your life, and immediately, you reshape the world to make this disaster the secret heartbeat of all things, the buried truth of the universe.

Falling in Love

Richard

After meeting Jan, my life changed drastically, like a whirlwind sweeping through a quiet town. Just a few days earlier, I had been going about my routine, unaware of the impending storm of emotions. When Jan and I finally embraced, our lips met in a deep, fervent kiss that left me breathless. It was a kiss that surpassed all our previous sweet moments, igniting a fire within me that left me feeling weightless, as if I were soaring through the air. It was a kiss so electrifying that I half believed it could have knocked my boots off if I had not been wearing them. In that instant, our love for each other was forever sealed.

Coming back to East Williamsburg on Monday morning after meeting Jan, I was on cloud nine. My smile was as wide as the Grand Canyon. As I walked into my basement office at St. John’s Lutheran Church on Maujer Street, I hoped others might be just as happy for me.

We were a little worried when you didn’t return yesterday,” Mark laughed.

I had always wanted to be a bandleader, even without musical talent; I laughed and began leading them through the highlights of the last thirty-two hours. “After you guys left, we talked and cleaned up all night…” I told them about the bagel run, the Rose, walking over most of the City, and taking the Staten Island Ferry. I hoped they could see how happy I was in love.

They all congratulated me, and some gave me high fives.

By the end of the week, Vanessa, a neighbor and friend, spoke to me while I waited to board the subway to visit Jan. “We are all thrilled you have found love, but it is normal and not something people boast about.” I looked at her and felt dejected but did not know how to respond. She filled the empty void. People fall in love or get laid daily, but it is not…” The arriving train kept me from hearing the end of her comment. Riding the L train, I knew I had wanted to say that it wasn’t about getting laid but falling in love that made me happy. But I was not sure I wanted to admit we had only kissed. Switching to the A train, I felt relaxed and knew I needed to tone down my exuberance, but not how much I loved Jan.

I had long dreamt of finding genuine, enduring love, which finally became a reality. This experience taught me that love is a fleeting emotion and an everlasting force that outlives everything. As we parted ways for work, a tender kiss confirmed that our love is eternal. This transformative power of love, which transcends time and never fades, has inspired me to remain a romantic, helping me overcome the loss of my wife. It’s a comforting reminder that love, in its most valid form, never truly dies.

The First Widow

In the early days of grief,” I explained to Bruce, a retired Lutheran minister, “I felt as if my entire world had collapsed. I don’t believe I felt that way, but some widows act as if they were the first person in the world to lose a spouse.” Bruce chuckled as we walked. Imagine the first person to become a widow, to watch the first person die?” We both agreed it would have been shocking to find our partner had died when we had no idea that our lives would end.

As we turned a corner, I shared with Bruce, a retired Lutheran minister, that I was not the first or last person to become a widow. I had heard that approximately 2800 people become new widows daily in the US. ‘Wow, I did not know there were that many,’ Bruce responded. If we are to have love, it is a risk we must accept.’ I nodded and responded that none of us would live forever, and to choose not to love because I feared I might one day grieve was not logical. This shared experience of grief, this understanding that we are not alone in our loss, can bring us together and help us heal. It’s a reminder that we are all part of a larger community, and our shared experiences can be a source of strength and comfort.

When Jan died, I explained to Bruce that my life had collapsed as I did not know how I could live without her. Although I had not read Kala aa, it had not been published. I understood why Helen would describe how a catastrophe cut through my life, and immediately, I reshaped the world to make this disaster the secret heartbeat of all things.

I had been hurt, and I believed my life would never be the same again. I wanted everyone to focus on me as if I were the first person in the world to lose a loved one. When my boys were young, I played Oregon Trail with them. As much as I enjoyed being a pioneer in the game, I was not and did not want to be a pioneer in grief. But not knowing how to grieve or make myself whole again, for the first few months, I viewed my experience as a life-consuming tragedy. They were not the best days of my life, and I knew if I continued to talk only about my pain from losing Jan, my family, friends, and neighbors would see me as a grumpy old widow. I knew I had to change and focus not on my loss but on my better, selfless nature. We chatted until we returned home and had a glass of water.

Reflecting on that conversation with Bruce in May 2023, I understand that creating a memorial garden for Jan was a turning point in my life. Despite the considerable emotional and financial investment, I saw it as a crucial step in redirecting my attention from my concerns to the needs of others. The project kept me dedicated to a selfless endeavor. I chose to work to overcome my grief even though I had no experience or confidence it would succeed. It did more than succeed in creating the garden; it helped me to volunteer, immerse myself in books, spend time outdoors, and get involved in my community. I embraced the task of facing each day as it came, adapting to life without Jan. This process of overcoming grief, step by step, gave meaning and purpose to my shattered life, inspiring me to find resilience and a new sense of self.

Pages: 1 2

20 comments add your comment

Share your thoughts and ideas

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Jan Lilien Education Fund!

Leadership: In Turbulent Times

Read: January 2019

Get this book

Leadership: In Turbulent Times

by Doris Kearns Goodwin

A Book for Our Turbulent Times

Leadership: In Turbulent Times by Doris Kearns Goodwin, one of America’s best presidential historians, offers an illuminating exploration of the early development, growth and exercise of leadership as demonstrated by Presidents Lincoln, Theodore Roosevelt, FDR and Johnson.

I received this book for Hanukkah from my granddaughter and son Mike and his girlfriend Elyssa. They know me very well. A book by Ms. Goodwin is always a must read. If you add in Lincoln, the two Roosevelt’s and LBJ, it is a book I cannot put down.

This NPR interview with Ms. Goodwin is worth listening to.

Subscribe

Contact Us

×
Three Summers

Read: February 2025

Get this book

Three Summers: A Novel

by Margarita Liberaki

Today, I began reading Margarita Liberaki‘s Three Summers, translated by Karen Van Dyck. This edition features a detailed introduction by Ms. Van Dyck, in which she shares her experiences meeting Ms. Liberaki and collaborating with her on the translation. The original novel, written in Greek, was titled The Straw Hats, but Ms. Van Dyck felt that this title would not resonate with foreign readers similarly.

Three Summers is the story of three sisters who grew up in the countryside near Athens before the outbreak of the Second World War. The sisters live in a large, old house surrounded by a beautiful garden. The oldest sister, Maria, is adventurous and eager to settle down and start her own family. The middle sister, Infanta, is gorgeous but emotionally distant. Katerina, the narrator, and the youngest sister is dreamy and rebellious.

Throughout three summers, the sisters share and keep secrets, fall in and out of love, and try to understand their parents and other adult figures. They also observe the peculiar behaviors of friends and neighbors while worrying about and discovering their identities. Karen Van Dyck’s translation beautifully captures the light and warmth of this modern Greek classic.

Margarita Liberaki (1919-2001) was born in Athens and raised by her grandparents, who owned the Fexis bookstore and publishing house. In addition to her novel Three Summers, she authored The Other Alexander (1950) and The Mystery (1976). She also wrote several plays, including Candaules’ Wife (1955) and The Danaïds (1956), part of a cycle she called Mythical Theater. Furthermore, she contributed screenplays, such as Jules Dassin’s Phaedra (1962) and Diaspora (1999), which focused on Greek intellectuals in exile in Paris during the junta. Her novel Three Summers is now a standard part of public education in Greece and Cyprus and was adapted into a television miniseries in 1995.

Karen Van Dyck is the Kimon A. Doukas Professor of Modern Greek Literature at Columbia University. Her research focuses on modern Greek literature, diaspora literature, gender studies, and translation. She has edited or co-edited several poetry anthologies, including A Century of Greek Poetry (2004), The Greek Poets: Homer to the Present (2010), and Austerity Measures: The New Greek Poetry (2017) for NYRB Poets. Additionally, her translations have appeared in Brooklyn Rail, Asymptote, and The Baffler.



When you purchase a book through one of my links, I earn a small commission that helps support my passion for reading. This contribution allows me to buy even more books to share with you, creating an incredible cycle of discovering great reads together! Your support truly makes a difference!


×
Clean: A Novel

Read: October 2024

Get this book

Clean: A Novel

by Alia Trabucco Zerán

Today, I delved into the unique narrative of ‘Clean: A Novel‘ by Alia Trabucco Zerán, translated by Sophie Hughes. This compelling novel, shortlisted for the Femina Etranger and Medicis Etranger Prizes, unfolds the story of a maid who has witnessed a lot and a family on the brink of collapse. The narrative is centered around a young girl’s death, with the family’s maid being the critical witness under interrogation, tasked with recounting the events leading up to the tragedy.

Estela’s journey from the countryside, leaving her mother behind, to work for the señor and señora when their only child was born is poignant. Their ad for a housemaid: ‘Smart appearance, full-time,’ was her ticket to earning enough to support her mother and return home. Estela cleaned their laundry, wiped their floors, and made their meals for seven years, but she also became privy to their secrets, witnessed their conflicts, and raised their daughter. She heard the rats in the ceiling, saw the looks the señor gave the señora, and knew about the poison in the cabinet, the gun, the daughter’s rebellion, the mother’s coldness, and the father’s distance. She experienced it all.

After a series of shocking betrayals and revelations, Estela’s silence becomes her shield, broken only now to reveal how it all unraveled. Is this a tale of vengeance or a confession? A clash of classes or a lesson in caution? With each page turn, ‘Clean: A Novel‘ builds tension, offering a gripping, incisive exploration of power, domesticity, and betrayal from an international star at the peak of her storytelling prowess.

×
The Candy House

Read: December 2022

Get this book

The Candy House: A Novel

by Jennifer Egan

The Candy House: A Novel by Jennifer Egan focuses on a new technology that allows you access to every memory you’ve ever had and to share your memories in exchange for access to the memories of others—it has seduced multitudes. According to the NYTimes, “this is minimalist maximalism. As a widow, I live in a world of memories, but I would not want them shared as they are in The Candy House. “It’s as if Egan compressed a big 19th-century novel onto a flash drive.”

Of course, I am not able to access my unconscious memories. Albeit in an amateur way, I write down some of my memories as they remind me of the power of the love that Jan and I shared. For example, the essay when I met Jan rekindles the memory and attempts to tell the story the way it happened, not how some would like it to be remembered.

The Candy House is one of the NYTimes’ top five fiction books of 2022. I have read two of them, The Furrows and Checkout 19. Initially, I was overwhelmed by the multitude of characters and was confused. By the novel’s middle, their interconnectedness helped me understand its real meaning. In the end, Egan delivers a fierce and exhilarating testament to the tenacity and transcendence of human longing for authentic connection, love, family, privacy, and redemption. As a widow, authenticity Is what I need to heal.

The Candy House is the seventieth (70) book I have read this year. 

The Goodreads summary provides an overview.

It’s 2010. Staggeringly successful and brilliant tech entrepreneur Bix Bouton is desperate for a new idea. He’s forty, with four kids, and restless when he stumbles into a conversation with mostly Columbia professors, one of whom is experimenting with downloading or “externalizing” memory. Within a decade, Bix’s new technology, Own Your Unconscious—that allows you access to every memory you’ve ever had and to share every memory in exchange for access to the memories of others—has seduced multitudes. But not everyone.

In spellbinding linked narratives, Egan spins out the consequences of Own Your Unconscious through the lives of multiple characters whose paths intersect over several decades. Egan introduces these characters in an astonishing array of styles—from omniscient to first person plural to a duet of voices, an epistolary chapter, and a chapter of tweets. In the world of Egan’s spectacular imagination, there are “counters” who track and exploit desires and “eluders” who understand the price of taking a bite of the Candy House.

Intellectually dazzling and extraordinarily moving, The Candy House is a bold, brilliant imagining of a world that is moments away. With a focus on social media, gaming, and alternate worlds, you can almost experience moving among dimensions in a role-playing game.​ Egan delivers a fierce and exhilarating testament to the tenacity and transcendence of human longing for real connection, love, family, privacy, and redemption.


The Jan Lilien Education Fund sponsors ongoing sustainability and environmental awareness programs. Gifts made this month; I will match dollar-for-dollar. All donations are tax-deductible.

Subscribe

Contact Us

I receive a commission when you buy a book or product using a link on this page. Thank you for supporting Sharing Jan’s Love blog.



×
Trust

Read: December 2022

Get this book

Trust by Hernan Diaz

by Hernan Diaz

Trust by Hernan Diaz is an elegant, multifaceted epic that recovers the voices buried under the myths that justify our foundational inequality; Trust is a literary triumph with a beating heart and urgent stakes. The novel is divided into four sections, each engaging and reminding us of the tremendous costs a fortune imposes on those who accumulate wealth. I highly recommend this novel as it is one of the best books I have ever read!

The first section is from Bonds, a successful novel about Benjamin and Helen Rask. Before finishing this section, I was so engrossed that I wanted their story to continue. The second is a memoir of Andrew Bevel, a successful fourth-generation financier, with notations on edits and corrections.

The third section is about Ida Partenza, an Italian-American novelist hired to flesh out Bevel’s memoir. The dynamics between her and Bevel, as well as her father and boyfriend, clarify the storyline and give it depth. Ms. Partenza seeks to find the truth, revealed in the fourth section, comprised of excerpts from Mildred’s diary. Suffice it to say; the admitted fact underscores the burdens of wealth and the antiquated views that limited women’s roles.

Trust is one of the NY Times’ top five fiction books of 2022. I have read four of them, Demon Copperhead, The Candy House, The Furrows, and Checkout 19. Trust was the fifth and the seventy-second book I have read this year. 

The Goodreads summary provides an overview.

Even though the roar and effervescence of the 1920s, everyone in New York has heard of Benjamin and Helen Rask. He is a legendary Wall Street tycoon; she is the brilliant daughter of eccentric aristocrats. Together, they have risen to the very top of seemingly endless wealth. But the secrets around their affluence and grandeur incite gossip. At what cost have they acquired their immense fortune? Rumors about Benjamin’s financial maneuvers and Helen’s reclusiveness start to spread–all as a decade of excess and speculation draws to an end.

This is the mystery at the center of a successful 1938 novel, Bonds, which all of New York seems to have read. But it isn’t the only version.

Hernan Diaz’s Trust brilliantly puts the story of these characters into conversation with other accounts–and in tension with the life and perspective of a young woman bent on disentangling fact from fiction. Provocative and propulsive, Trust engages the reader in a quest for the truth while confronting the reality-warping gravitational pull of money and how power often manipulates facts. The result is a novel that becomes more exhilarating and profound with each new layer and revelation.


The Jan Lilien Education Fund sponsors ongoing sustainability and environmental awareness programs. Gifts made this month; I will match dollar-for-dollar. All donations are tax-deductible.

Subscribe

Contact Us

I receive a commission when you buy a book or product using a link on this page. Thank you for supporting Sharing Jan’s Love blog.



×
All the Sinners Bleed- A Novel

Read: June 2023

Get this book

All the Sinners Bleed: A Novel

by S. A. Cosby

Today, I delved into the gripping pages of “All the Sinners Bleed” by S. A. Cosby. This enthralling novel centers around Titus Crown, the first African American sheriff in Charon County, Virginia. Despite the county’s reputation for traditional customs such as moonshine, cornbread, and honeysuckle, Titus, with his FBI expertise, knows that the peace won’t last forever.

On the first anniversary of Titus’s election, a schoolteacher is murdered by an ex-student, and Titus’s deputies take down the perpetrator. As Titus delves deeper into the case, he uncovers a web of horrendous crimes and finds a serial killer lurking in plain sight, haunting Charon’s dirt roads and woodland clearings.

Titus is determined to solve the case, despite its connection to a nearby church, and he harbors a personal secret that haunts him. However, he faces opposition from a far-right group that wants to hold a parade to honor the town’s Confederate past while he tries to solve the issue.

Despite the challenges, Titus remains resolute in his love for Charon and his commitment to finding justice. The collision of religion and hatred cannot deter him from his duty.


S. A. Cosby is a New York Times bestselling writer from southeastern Virginia. He is the author of All the Sinners Bleed, which was on more than forty Best of the Year lists, including Barack Obama’s, as well as Edgar Award finalist Razorblade Tears and Los Angeles Times Book Prize winner Blacktop Wasteland. He has also won the Anthony Award, ITW Thriller Award, Barry Award, Macavity Award, BCALA Award, and Audie Award. He has been longlisted for the ALA Andrew Carnegie Medal for Excellence.



When you purchase a book through one of my links, I earn a small commission that helps support my passion for reading. This contribution allows me to buy even more books to share with you, creating an incredible cycle of discovering great reads together! Your support truly makes a difference!

Enjoy a limited-time offer of 20% off your next book purchase at Bookshop.org!


×

Discover more from Sharing Jan’s Love

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading